The Winter Meeting of the Delaware Valley Medieval Association – Saturday, December 12, 2026 10:00-5:00

“Masters of Learned Ignorance: Reflections on Symbolic Negation, De docta ignorantia, and Mystical Theology in Honor of Dr. Donald Duclow”

The Inn at Villanova – Villanova University

Saturday, December 12th, 2026  

10:00-10:15 Opening Address

Thomas Izbicki (Rutgers University)

10:30-12:30 Keynote Session One

Chris Bellitto (Kean University)

“The Medieval Gift of the Humility of Learned Ignorance”

One of the great insights that Donald Duclow offered was how learned ignorance was valued in the Middle Ages. This presentation offers a closer look at several figures who championed learned ignorance as an aspect of humility: Bernard of Clairvaux, Al-Ghazali, Jean Gerson, Nicolas de Clamanges, and Nicholas of Cusa. We will conclude with a few remarks on the medieval legacy of humility and learned ignorance in an age of AI.

Maarten Halff (Independent Scholar)

“Cusanus’ encounters with ‘monstrosities’: the De docta ignorantia through the lens of external phenomenon”

If in his De docta ignorantia Cusanus proposed a pathway to knowing God – and not just as a mystical theology but also as a method, one that he “discovered” by experiencing it himself – then it is of importance to inquire what the starting point to his experience was. In pursuing this inquiry, scholars have been both captivated and confounded by a passage in Cusanus’ dedicatory letter to Cardinal Giuliano Cesarini, in which he alluded to a revelation while at sea – a “celestial gift from the Father of Lights.” What has received much less attention is that, in the prologue to his work, Cusanus also framed his undertaking through the act of wondering and the physical encounter with the wondrous: echoing Plato and Aristotle, he identified wondering as the cause of philosophy and as stimulant to intellect, attributing particular thought-provoking effect to wondering at “the unusual, even monstrous [monstra].” Are these two passages related, and could they refer to the same seaboard experience? Through an analysis of over a hundred accounts from the fifteenth century of sea travel in the eastern Mediterranean, I demonstrate that encounters with light phenomena caused by an electric discharge around ship masts were recorded with some frequency, including by Sylvester Syropoulos, a Byzantine prelate on the same convoy that Cusanus traveled on. Moreover, these accounts often include descriptions of the profound impact on the perceivers, in terms that closely resemble those of Cusanus. Seen in this light – as an encounter with a wonder-inspiring natural phenomenon – Cusanus’ seaboard experience opens up a new way to approach his doctrine of learned ignorance.

12:30-1:45 Lunch 

1:45-3:45 Keynote Session Two  

Erin Risch Zoutendam (Seton Hall University)

“Love and Mystical Theology in the Middle Ages”

This paper considers medieval encounters between the Song of Songs and the corpus of Pseudo-Dionysius—two powerful currents in the “new mysticism” that arose around 1200. It focuses particularly on the bridal metaphor of the Song of Songs and argues that the use of this metaphor in Dionysian texts was not merely pretextual but rather generated new ways of thinking and speaking. I conclude that the bridal metaphor of the Song of Songs was instrumental in transforming Dionysian mystical theology, providing it with new language, methods, aims, and practices.

Kevin Hughes (Villanova University)

The Poverty of Unknowing: Angela of Foligno and how ‘learned ignorance’ is figured among the ‘unlearned’”

Donald Duclow defined ‘learned ignorance’ as “a theory of knowledge where one uses symbolic expressions to reflect on human finitude.”  The term is used most prominently in Nicholas of Cusa, but it is profitably applied retrospectively among the genealogy of those thinkers, from Dionysius to Eriugena to Eckhart.  In this paper, I want to explore in a comparative way how some of these same strategies look in a different register. Angela of Foligno is not in this Dionysian speculative tradition, and yet her ‘Book” is full of “symbolic expressions reflecting on human finitude.”  Is Angela part of the broader “learned ignorance” tradition?  Does her figuration of knowing and limit differ in significant ways?  If so, how are they significant?  Essentially, how do we think about various strands of apophatic theology in relation to one another?

3:45-5:00 Light Refreshments 

*Please see the calendar below for registration information.

Stay tuned for more upcoming meetings.

Loading…

The Inn offers on-site parking. For additional travel information, please see The Inn at Villanova or call 610-519-8000.